Tuesday, May 27, 2025

Sounding Truths Fostered in the Classroom

This reading stirred such an ache, a fire and call to examine the often invisible dynamics that shape our classrooms and, by extension, our communities. In Other People’s Children, author Lisa Delpit speaks directly to the painful disconnect between some educators’ intentions and the lived realities of the children they serve. As someone who knows what it means to be misjudged, unheard, and overlooked in systems never built for me, I felt her words resonate on a soul level. Delpit doesn’t tiptoe around the truth…blatantly names and proclaims exactly where the issues lie. She reminds us that love, care, and intention are not enough when power, privilege, and cultural assumptions remain unexamined. In this season of my life where healing, justice, and advocacy guide my every step, her work reaffirms the urgency of showing up differently and purposefully, for our children, patients, and selves.

Main Argument (Thesis):
This author, Lisa Delpit, argues that educational inequities persist when white, middle-class teachers fail to recognize the cultural strengths, language styles, and learning needs of children of color. True progress requires humility, self-awareness, and a commitment to shifting the power dynamics within our classrooms.

Three Talking Points That Moved Me:

1. Power Shapes the Conversation Even When We Don’t See It 

“Those with power are frequently least aware of or least willing to acknowledge its existence. Those of less power are often most aware of its existence”- Lisa Delprit 

This quote reminded me that awareness is the foundation of justice. I've lived through systems where my voice was misread or silenced, not out of malice, but because someone in power assumed they already knew better. That assumption is harm cloaked in good intent. We must learn to hear what we’ve been trained to ignore.

Question to sit with:  When have I mistaken my perspective as universal truth?

2. Equity Means Caring for All Children Equally

“I want the same thing for everyone else's children as I want for mine.” — Lisa Delpit

This quote struck me deeply. It calls us to extend care and commitment beyond our own circles, demanding that every child receives the same dedication, respect, and opportunity. As a holistic nurse and minority woman, I see how systems often favor some while neglecting others. Delpit’s words remind me that true justice requires holding all children to the same high standard without limitations or exceptions

Personal reflection: Change comes when we expand our compassion and act with accountability, ensuring no child is left behind. This is the call I carry in my healing and advocacy work. How can I live out this commitment daily to uplift every child as if they were my own?

 Communication Styles Matter: Cultural Misunderstandings in the Classroom
“It’s really a shame but she (that Black teacher upstairs) seems to be so authoritarian, so focused on skills and so teacher-directed. Those poor kids never seem to be allowed to really express their creativity (and she even yells at them).” Lisa Delpit

This quote reflects a common and harmful misinterpretation rooted in cultural misunderstanding. Delpit explains that Black educators often use a more direct and explicit communication style, grounded in cultural norms where clear commands are a sign of care, structure, and high expectations. In contrast, white educators often use indirect, suggestive language, assuming this approach nurtures independence and creativity. Delpit writes, “White children tend to respond to indirect statements and Black children to direct ones.” This mismatch in language and expectation can cause Black teachers to be unfairly labeled as harsh, and Black students to be misunderstood or disciplined for noncompliance.

Personal reflection: As a Caribbean woman and nurse leader, I know that clarity in communication is not domination. It is all spoken out of protection, culture, intention, and love. Understanding how culture shapes expression is essential to equity in both education and healthcare. What must I unlearn to serve more fully, more justly?

Final Reflection:

Lisa Delpit’s work is the sounding truth that is needed in our classrooms today. Her words are a mirror and a roadmap that pave paths of healing, education, and justice to students all throughout the world.  We cannot transform systems we are unwilling to examine. Let us listen deeply, teach courageously, and lead with hearts wide open.



3 comments:

  1. I love your questions to sit with and this one I am sitting with:

    When have I mistaken my perspective as universal truth?

    And I think that when it comes to raising children I think that Black families have more obedient (may not be the right word) children than white folks. When I see children misbehaving and the mother or father is just like oh johnny do not do that and Johnny just gets more crazy...... I smh like now if that was my mother we would know better.

    So I do admit that we sometimes as black think we have all the answers too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. As you quoted, I agree that communication styles do matter. It's inevitable that a mixture of all kinds of children will be in any given class. How do we gear the communication style to each student if their needs are so different?

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Equity Means Caring for All Children Equally" Yes!!!!! And listening to all voices equally.

    ReplyDelete

Voices in Motion: Learning from the Bilingual Classroom

  Watching the CUNY-NYSIEB Teaching Bilinguals (Even If You’re Not One)  web series felt like coming home to a classroom I’ve long dreamed o...